Call of Fate Homepage
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Calendar   Register Register  Login Login

Inception ** SPOILER THREAD **

 Post Reply Post Reply
Author
  Topic Search Topic Search  Topic Options Topic Options
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: Inception ** SPOILER THREAD **
    Posted: Jul-21-10 at 8:57pm
There, now we can discuss that ending.

Here's my take:
He's in a dream. But it's a dream of his own creation.
I think he gave up on any hope of returning home to see his kids at some point. Whether
from guilt, the law, or a combination of the two.  Since he couldn't take it anymore, he
escaped into the dream world, far down where he knew that his real-life body would be
dead before he ever had to deal with waking up.

However, having already lived in the dream world with his wife and discovering that knowing
it's a dream ruins any chance of taking it seriously, he needed to create an Idea so strong
it could enthrall even him. So the elaborate plan goes as such:

The one thing he wants more than anything else is to live with his children again. Chasing
that idea alone couldn't fool him. So the Maze is set to where he's given a rare opportunity,
by someone powerful enough to accomplish the feat, to clear his name and return home.
To take advantage of this, he must perform an almost impossible mission; a mission so
dangerous that he won't have time to wonder at the difference between the real world
and that world. A danger so terrifying (getting killed and ending up spending an eternity in
limbo) that he can only focus on the task at hand.

And when he completes the mission, and earns his prize, he's so relieved he doesn't
pause for a moment. He accepts his reward whole-heartily. He doesn't even look back
to watch the spinner.
_______________________________________

Now, here's how I pieced that together.
1. He's brilliant. He knows all the tricks and he understands the human psyche; especially his own.
2. His subconscious continues to try and warn him during the film. Doing this could be
viewed as a Leap Of Faith on his part- trusting in his own ability to fool even himself and
escape the pain. At least twice during the film, important Projections told him just that:
Take a Leap of Faith.
3. He calls in "specialists" of their fields... yet he's always the one with the answers. This
further points at everyone being his Projections.
4. The difficulties he faces in the film are over-the-top. Running into an alley that continues
to narrow until he only just squeeze through; a target that's been trained against his
skill-set with armed guards suddenly appearing to increase the difficulty at just the right
moment; and lastly, when all else fails, throw in a crazed, vengeful wife to interfere.
5. When he finally gets back to his kids... they look EXACTLY like he remembered them. Kids
noticebly age very quickly. He wouldn't have stepped into the exact same scene had it
been the real world. But as seen above, by that time he was so grateful at being alive
and making it back, he didn't stop to question.
Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-22-10 at 3:26pm
Nice analysis! Just a couple of thoughts on things I need to ponder a bit more:

The top was his wife's... you never see him with one of his own. Did she ever exist? His kids? They say he was lost in limbo for some time before he "got out" But then if you discard any of it as real then the story if pointless so <shrug> we will assume that she and the kids are "real" but then why doesn't he have a touchstone of his own?

The old man in the beginning and the end has still got my brain twisted in knots. I need to see it again LOL I have a feeling this will be one I will see a few times before I am satisfied I have a grasp on it.
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-22-10 at 5:18pm
The old man? You mean Saito (Ken Watanabe)?
When he died, he dropped down to what I can only assume is the deepest level of sleep.
Therefore, by the time Cobb (Dicaprio) finds and gets to him many, many decades have
past for Saito. That's why he's old as hell. To Cobb, it may have taken him a month of his
time to get to Saito's plane of existence, and in the month Saito continued to age about
50 years, for example. Once on Saito's plane, it could have taken Cobb only a day to reach the now 90-year old Saito.

As for Cobb's totem... I don't know. I wondered the same thing and came up with:
if he were going to create a reality for himself that he never planned to return from, he
wouldn't WANT a totem. Then, inside the dream world, he picks up a dream-totem. It could,
therefore, more completely tie him to that reality and keeping him from waking up.


Edited by McCordRm - Jul-22-10 at 5:22pm
Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-23-10 at 1:35am
I got the aged Saito thing but he was there in the beginning and at the end. Was it just flashback after his first appearance and we see the rest of it at the end? Going Monday to see it in IMAX this time. Loved the folding city so this should be fun.
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-23-10 at 4:19am
Ah... it's one of those, "Let's get back to where we were" things. The movie begins at near the end of the
story, then flashes back to play catch-up.

OH! I forgot to write the freakin title of the movie.
It's called Inception, and more than once Cobb comments that he's done it before.
SO, the basis of my analysis was that the whole movie was about him performing
an elaborate Inception on himself.


Edited by McCordRm - Jul-23-10 at 4:22am
Back to Top
Ebon-WE View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar

Joined: Sep-13-04
Location: Arizona
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1166

Gravebender WoW(A)
Slump WoW(A)
Fulltone WoW(A)
  Quote Ebon-WE Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-23-10 at 5:51am
He dropped the totem in the bathroom scene. Was the rest a dream from there?
Innuender's Game
Back to Top
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-23-10 at 5:38pm
? He dropped it on the floor when Saito walked in... but then he picked it back up.
Still, it was his wife's Top. I never saw him use any other item.


Edited by McCordRm - Jul-23-10 at 5:39pm
Back to Top
Ebon-WE View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar

Joined: Sep-13-04
Location: Arizona
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1166

Gravebender WoW(A)
Slump WoW(A)
Fulltone WoW(A)
  Quote Ebon-WE Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 2:07am
I'm diggin' this thread.

I guess I should have been a little more specific. Just wanted to toss this out there.

Cobb was testing out that drug in the basement. When he was supposed to awaken, he couldn't shake the images of his wife. So he whipped it out (his totem). But he never got a chance to spin it. He was interrupted by Saito.

If it spun forever, he was in a dream. If it rattled, and fell, he was in reality. Right?

I was figuring that once he tried the drug, he was out. Didn't see the top spin in that scene, and the top doesn't fall at the end? Dream.

Cobb had, at one point in the film stated the importance of having a totem particular to your being. He adopted the top as his totem once his waifu died (what did he use as a totem prior? or was this the conception of it? I don't remember). And later we found the importance of the weight and such of the top. 

I like ideas thrown in this thread! If his wife was fictitious, then the top doesn't matter.

The great thing about this movie is that it can be so widely interpreted. I need to see it again after reading through the different p.o.v's


Edited by Ebon-WE - Jul-24-10 at 2:11am
Innuender's Game
Back to Top
Anweir View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Guild Space Cadet

Joined: Jun-01-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 3145

Anweir lotro
Anwar lotro
Perriman lotro
  Quote Anweir Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 12:22pm
I have to wonder how the totems work if it's your subconscious that's forming the dream.  After all, you know what the totem is supposed to be like.  Hence, so does your subconscious.  I think the totems would only work when you are in someone else's dream.

My take:  Mol (his wife) was right when she jumped.  They were still in a dream - his initial dream with his wife.  Hence, the top is useless to him as a totem - it will do whatever his subconscious needs it to do, spin or fall.  He couldn't deal with her absence and created the rest as outlined by McCordRm in the first post
Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 4:05pm
BUT did the top fall in the end? They did that abrupt "lights out" as it was spinning but it had wobbled a bit and looked like it Might fall.

The girl's totem... you purposely do not see it clearly but from what little you do see it looked like a chess piece bishop. Cobb's piece, his wife's top, spun to let him know if he was still in a dream but you never see the other people's totems, just the girl. What would hers do if she were to use it to determine where she was.
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 4:10pm
Definately going back Monday for the IMAX but mainly cause I will be sitting there watching for all the little things I missed. I am with you Ebon, love the P.O.Vs here. Oh yeah Hy, I assumed the totem was a deeper meaning sort of thing that would sort of act like the "falling" trigger. Something that you invest spirit in beyond what your brain would create for the dream. I think you interpretation fits best with what I am getting from it. LOL wait til I get back from it Monday = )
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
thune View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Title Prevaricator

Joined: Jan-10-03
Location: L.I. New York
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 6068

Aquis WAR
kinelli WAR
keblog WAR
  Quote thune Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 5:23pm
really enjoyed it only prblem it was 90% full and I was to closeDisapprove
Back to Top
Logain View Drop Down
WoW Moderator
WoW Moderator
Avatar
Suicide Pimp

Joined: Oct-09-05
Location: Piney woods
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 3336

Logain WoW(A)
Kamyra WoW(A)
Nogain WoW(A)
  Quote Logain Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 5:44pm

old people know the regrets of children better than most, and they keep the picture of thier children (no matter thier age) as them very young. 

 
Saito was there at the begining and the end.  Young then old.  I figgure Cobb may have been Saito's image of himself

Woodrow Wilson:
The ear of the leader must ring with the voices of the people.
Back to Top
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-24-10 at 5:54pm
Originally posted by Anweir

My take:  Mol (his wife) was right when she jumped.  They were still in a dream - his initial dream with his wife.  Hence, the top is useless to him as a totem - it will do whatever his subconscious needs it to do, spin or fall.  He couldn't deal with her absence and created the rest as outlined by McCordRm in the first post


My problem with that is this:
The pieces shown to you later where they clearly reach old age in the dreamworld.
When she jumps, they're young again.

Granted, he if they were deep enough when they got old, they could have
theoretically just woken up a level or two. SO, it does make you wonder how she
could have been so convinced she was still dreaming. Did the totem tell her?
Back to Top
Burt View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar
Lord of the Dance

Joined: Jun-01-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 3651

Burt WoW(A)
Ventralis the Imperiler FF
Ventralis WoW(A)
  Quote Burt Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-25-10 at 9:53pm
I saw this over the weekend... I feel like Inception and the Matrix both took half of the Neuromancer dynamic. The Matrix is obvious (loner computer hacker, vast cyber network, all that BS). Inception had:

- a dead lover that haunts the protagonist throughout
- main character is being held hostage to redeem himself or make him whole
- it's all premised on shadowy/vague international corporate politics
- important shots on the beach with his wife
- a character in the team that specializes in deception


That's really my only observation. Real good flick
Back to Top
Alx View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Happy Bouncing Member

Joined: Jun-27-03
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4508

Myzme WoW(A)
Allyx WoW(A)
Ennara WoW(A)
  Quote Alx Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-26-10 at 2:10pm
I was convinced that the dream world was his once they found that the mind had previous training against people in dreams. Seemed more far-fetched that some random billionaire had the training, rather than that they were in his own mind. The totem does wobble at the end. Leaves much room for interpretation.


Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-26-10 at 7:20pm
He spins the top and walks away not caring if it falls or not. After a second viewing I am pretty hot on the idea that he is still lost in the dream and that all of the prompting along the way is a number of attempts made by his own subconscious to tell him that he IS still dreaming. All of the people he has on his team are great representations of aspects of his own psyche.
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
thune View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Title Prevaricator

Joined: Jan-10-03
Location: L.I. New York
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 6068

Aquis WAR
kinelli WAR
keblog WAR
  Quote thune Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-26-10 at 9:49pm
I feel he escaped in the "dream".He never looks at his childrens faces in life. He spins the top and looks at them. it starts to falter as he walks away IMHO
Back to Top
Handaar View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar

Joined: Jun-03-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 3759

Handaar WAR
Raichean WAR
Raadnah WAR
  Quote Handaar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Jul-27-10 at 6:17pm
Yeah.. pretty thin, but he made a BIG deal about not seeing the faces of his kids.  A point for escaping.. but then again his kids were in the same place, SAME CLOTHES.. uh.. point against escape.
 
The top when it would just spin before was dead on straight, no wobble and it wobbles.. a think a weaker point that he got out, but then again we never actually saw it fall.. a point against..
 
So back to "I have no damn clue!"  8)
Immortals.. they fail my King's test. And a man who fancies himself a god feels a very human chill crawl up his spine.
Back to Top
Iss Hogai View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Iss Cube

Joined: Jun-01-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1780

Sandur lotro
Chrilin lotro
  Quote Iss Hogai Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Aug-09-10 at 12:17pm
Originally posted by Aiko Jade



The girl's totem... you purposely do not see it clearly but from what little you do see it looked like a chess piece bishop. Cobb's piece, his wife's top, spun to let him know if he was still in a dream but you never see the other people's totems, just the girl. What would hers do if she were to use it to determine where she was.
 
Actually Aiko, if you remember the one guys shows the girl his "Loaded Die" totem and he doesn't let her touch it, saying something to the effect of "I'm the only one who knows the weight and feel of it."  Later Ariadne refuses to let Cobb touch hers and he mentions she is learning.
 
What caught my attention was the use of the name Ariadne.  Ariadne in Greek Mythology was the one that gave Theseus the ball of twine to lead him back out of the labyrinth afte killing the Minotaur.  Yet another subconscious manifestation of trying to escape?
 
Just saw this for the first time this weekend as part of an anniversary night out. 

I told you I'm NOT a farmer!
Back to Top
Aiko Jade View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Mistress of Sagacity

Joined: May-20-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 4294

Aiko Jade WE
Symbol WoW(A)
  Quote Aiko Jade Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Aug-09-10 at 3:01pm
Hmmmm you are right Master Hogai - you do see Arthur's die and I assume that it would come up something besides what a "loaded" die would if he were still in the dream but what action would the bishop have? Yeah he mentioned weight and feel but your own perception is what you are trying to verify.... hmmmm
Aiko Jade
No good deed goes unpunished.
Back to Top
McCordRm View Drop Down
WoW Member
WoW Member
Avatar

Joined: Nov-11-04
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2093

Gatling WAR
Farwyn WAR
Athos WAR
  Quote McCordRm Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Aug-09-10 at 7:50pm
Originally posted by Iss Hogai

 
Actually Aiko, if you remember the one guys shows the girl his "Loaded Die" totem and he doesn't let her touch it, saying something to the effect of "I'm the only one who knows the weight and feel of it."  Later Ariadne refuses to let Cobb touch hers and he mentions she is learning.
 
What caught my attention was the use of the name Ariadne.  Ariadne in Greek Mythology was the one that gave Theseus the ball of twine to lead him back out of the labyrinth afte killing the Minotaur.  Yet another subconscious manifestation of trying to escape?
 
Just saw this for the first time this weekend as part of an anniversary night out. 

WOW... I'm pretty freakin' good at catching Mythology references and completely missed
that one. Aces, bud. I'm impressed.
Back to Top
Iss Hogai View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Iss Cube

Joined: Jun-01-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1780

Sandur lotro
Chrilin lotro
  Quote Iss Hogai Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Aug-09-10 at 10:48pm
To be perfectly honest, the name tickled the back of my mind during the movie and I had to look it up to see why.  Seemed maybe the fact that when they were talking about mazes at least a couple of times they mentioned Labyrinths. 
 
Makes me wonder if any of the other names have any significance.  Myles keeps making me think of the line of poetry used in the Charles Bronson Movie Telefon (yeah, I'm showing my age again).  The line of poetry was, "And miles to go before you sleep."   Some how that line of poetry keeps nagging me about this movie.

I told you I'm NOT a farmer!
Back to Top
Iss Hogai View Drop Down
CoF Traveler
CoF Traveler
Avatar
Iss Cube

Joined: Jun-01-02
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1780

Sandur lotro
Chrilin lotro
  Quote Iss Hogai Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: Aug-09-10 at 10:51pm
Aiko, like you I thought she was making a gold colored bishop also but I thought I saw a red ball at the base, maybe to let it roll a set distance?

I told you I'm NOT a farmer!
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Bulletin Board Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 9.08
Copyright ©2001-2008 Web Wiz

This page was generated in 0.266 seconds.